If you have ever owned a Discman, Tamagotchi, Beanie Baby, designer yo-yo, or even an AOL account, well, you might have grown up in the 90s. If you have a box full of your Beanie Babies gathering dust in the attic, then it is time to dust off the box and consider selling your Beanie Baby collection. 

If you are interested in putting some cash in your pocket, then keep reading our guide on the best place to sell your Beanie Babies. 

Beanie Baby Value

Some of your Beanie Babies could be worth serious cash. Depending on the Beanie Babies in your collection, you could bring home anywhere from a few dollars to a few thousand dollars. 

However, the Beanie Babies that rake in large amounts of cash are very rare. It is more likely that you will be able to sell your Beanie Babies for change or for just a couple of dollars. If they were just collecting dust in the attic, then this could be the perfect opportunity for some spring cleaning and a little extra money. 

Whether you are selling your beanie babies for cash or to reclaim space you need to know, where to sell your beanie babies. 

Where to Sell Beanie Babies

There are many options for various places to sell your Beanie Babies. However, when choosing where to sell, you not only want to get the best value, but you want to be sure that you are not paying more to sell them than you are getting in return. 

Are you having to pay for shipping? This could lead you to pay more to ship than you get in return. Heading to the pawnshop? Are you spending more on gas or in buying items in the pawnshop, than you are getting in return? 

Online Selling Platforms

Online selling platforms will offer you the ability to sell your Beanie Babies. Many online selling platforms will charge you a fee when you list your item for sale. This is already going to cut into your profits. 

You then need to consider shipping. Shipping could be paid, in part, by the buyer. However, if the rate the buyer pays for shipping does not match what it costs, then you are once again stuck footing the bill. 

In addition, you also need to make a trip to the post office and use gas and time. The perk of online selling platforms is you get to set your price, however, often the pricing can be confusing. 


There are some antiques and pawn shops that buy beanie babies. However, not every antique shop or pawn shop does. 

When looking at this option, you have to call or go to the various shops to find out whether or not they will buy your beanie babies. If they happen to buy them, then you will need to drive there to get quotes. 

The upside to selling here is supporting local businesses in your community. The downside is that it takes time away from your day and you may not get the best price. It is better to deal with a company that has knowledge of collectible toys. 


Another option is to sell your beanie babies to collectors. However, once again, unless you happen to have some super rare Beanie Babies sitting around the house, it may be difficult to sell to collectors. 

You will also have to take the time to find the platforms where collectors will be looking to buy Beanie Babies. 

Sell Beanie Babies to Plush Collector

In contrast to the options above, you could sell your Beanie Babies to Plush Collector. Plush Collector has been buying toys since 2012. There are many benefits to choosing to sell to Plush Collectors.

Find Quotes Online

Are you wondering how much your Beanie Baby is worth? In the, “Sell Now,” section of the website, you can see how much you will be paid for your Beanie Baby. 

Each Beanie Baby is listed with the price quote. You can also choose to sell in bulk. Bulk collections need to have 250 or more Beanie Babies. 

Standardized Prices

What you see is what you get, Plush Collectors seeks to be transparent. The quotes in the Sell Now section are the prices you will get. These standardized prices take the guesswork out of the selling process. 

Zero Per Transaction Selling Fees

We talked about online selling platforms that have selling fees, however, this is not the case with Plush Collectors. Plush Collectors does not take an unfair cut. They do not charge a selling fee per transaction. 

Prompt Payment

When it is time for you to get your payment, it comes in fast. You can choose to be paid via check or PayPal. This means you do not have to wait around for a long time for your payday to roll in. 

Shipping Costs

If your order is over 25 dollars, then Plush Collectors will cover your shipping costs. Ultimately, you do not want the cost to ship to eat into your order. With Plush Collectors, it does not have to. 

Safe and Secure

Plush Collectors site is encrypted and authenticated using TLS 1.2 SSL certificate. This means that your information is secure. You do not have to worry about the wrong people getting your data. 


The best part of selling your Beanie Babies to Plush Collectors is the simplicity. As the Jackson 5 would say, it’s easy as A, B, C, and as simple as 1, 2, 3. 

  1. Go online and submit your request for a quote
  2. Ship your toys
  3. Get paid 

This means you are not spending all day calling or driving to stores to see if they might buy your beanie babies. In addition, Plush Collectors has a user-friendly website, so you do not have to spend time being confused trying to figure out other online selling platforms. 

What Customers Say About Plush Collectors

Customers love Plush Collectors. Here are just a few things they say:

  • “A great service and communicative”
  • “They did a great job with my very large collection.”
  • “They are easy, honest, and fast!”
  • “I found them to be fast and efficient”
  • “I would highly recommend Plush Collector”
  • “Plush Collector offered me a very fair price, did everything they said they would do and I received my check in a timely manner”

Customers have many more great things to say about Plush Collectors. This is just a preview!  

Sell Your Beanie Babies Today

Now that you know where to sell beanie babies, are you ready? Get your beanie babies sold today with Plush Collectors. 

Plush Collectors will buy your Beanie Baby Collection and more. Find out more about how it works today and get the ball rolling. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.