If you were a kid in the 90s, beanie babies were all the rage. These cute characters came in all shapes and sizes. In a collector’s eyes, this means dollar signs.
Beauty is in the eye of the collector. What makes something more sought-after than other pieces?
It is a combination of rarity and uniqueness. If you are holding onto your beanie babies, consider collectibles insurance and selling them. Read our guide below to learn about the most expensive beanie babies out there.
1. Princess the Bear
When you think of expensive beanie babies, what is the first one that pops into your mind? For many, it is Princess the Bear, commemorating the tragic death of Princess Diana.
Released in 1997, Princess the Bear was created by Ty to raise money for The Diana, Princess of Wales Memorial Fund. Aside from the iconic nature, the beanie baby value also comes from how it’s made.
Most of these beanie babies were made with polyethylene (PE) pellets, which aren’t worth much. The ones that hold value are made from polyvinyl chloride (PVC) pellets. You can sell Princess the Bear beanie babies anywhere from $10,000-$600,000.
2. McDonald’s International Bears
In the 1990s, McDonald’s jumped on the bandwagon when they use to include ones in their happy meals. Teenie Babies quickly became an iconic moment in the franchise’s Happy Meal history.
In the International Bears collection, there are a total of four bears from four different countries. They are Glory from the U.S., Maple from Canada, Britannia from Britain, and Erin from Ireland.
If you happen to have the McDonald’s International Bears in their original packaging, you could sell those for upwards of $10,000.
3. Peace Bear
What sets the Peace Bear apart is its tie-dye pattern. This means that no two are the same, thus increasing its beanie baby value. The Peace Bear also sported different tags and was the first of its kind with an embroidered emblem.
If you hold the Peace Bear in mint condition, you can look to sell it for approximately $500. Head here to see how it works.
4. Valentino the Bear
When on the hunt for beanie babies worth money, Valentino the Bear is one of the most valuable on the market. In this case, the errors increase the bears’ value. These errors include a brown nose instead of black, PVC pellets, a white, rather than a yellow, star on the tag, and typos on the tag.
A rare Valentino with error could be worth a beanie baby value anywhere between $1,000-$42,300.
5. Iggy the Iguana
Other animals in the beanie babies kingdom hold value as well. One of which is Iggy Iguana, seeing many different design iterations throughout its lifespan. Collectors will love the fact that an Iggy may or may not have its tongue sticking out, rainbow or dark blue-colored, and a tag on its foot or spine.
The combination of character traits surely adds value. You can see the Iguana ty beanie babies being sold up to $5,000.
Sell Your Nostalgia With Beanie Babies
Are you holding onto your nostalgia? It may be time to let go and have someone else enjoy.
Now that you have a better understanding of which pieces hold value and why, take a look at your collection. Do you have any beanie babies worth money?
Head on over to Plush Collector and sell beanie babies today!