Selling for the Love of Beanies

You love your beanies, you loved collecting your Beanie Babies: the excitement of a new purchase waiting in line with other collectors to find the newest pieces, the thrill of a rare find. But how ‘rare’ is your collection? Ty made as many as 100 million of each style. So unless you have a 1st, 2nd or 3rd generation beanie baby they aren’t unique and rare. Most beanies are not as rare or valuable as you think. For the love of beanies, don’t let them sit in the attic, closet, garage, basement or storage collecting dust.

PlushCollector.com will make sure your little guys find a good home with a child to play with, someone who is just as excited as you once were to have a new friend to love.

Selling for the Money behind Beanies

Your once dear collection is taking up too much space in your closet. You need to move on. While the collector market has taken a giant nosedive, there is still a way to get a modest return on your investment.

PlushCollector.com will ensure you get the best price for your collection, whether you have common or rare beanies.

Selling Beanies to reclaim Space

Is your collection hogging up real estate? Feeling the space crunch? You’re not alone, it’s happened to many of our customers too.

Whether you are downsizing, feeling a bit cramped, need room for what ever extra special purchase, need to remodel for any reason, wifey/hubby says it has to go.. yikes! We are your #1 spot for selling your collection, regardless of size.

PlushCollector.com will pay $0.25 and up for most beanie models, and $5.00 to $50.00 for truly rare editions. There won’t be a big collectible value for your beanies again, according the Wall Street Journal, but you can make $50, $100, $200 or more by selling yours today. Plus you will have a good feeling knowing that your breathing new life into them by giving them to a child somewhere who can enjoy them as much as you once did.


Sell Beanies to Plush Collector – it is the quickest and safest way to trade your Beanies online, and make the most of your Ty Beanie Baby value.

To learn more about our process, see our How It Works page.