Did you know you can sell Beanie Babies for thousands of dollars? Sending your plush toys in for a Beanie Baby appraisal could be the best financial decision of your life if you have the right rare Beanie Babies. Many people have some of these valuable toys sitting on their shelves at home with no idea of how valuable they are.

In this article, we help you from missing out on your Beanie Babies’ value by explaining the Beanie Baby appraisal process. We discuss how factors such as supply and demand, item quality, and mint condition affect their value. Continue reading if you want to learn how to make money on your unused toys. 

Item Authenticity

The first step in a Beanie Baby appraisal is authentication. Ideally, you have a certificate of authenticity to accompany your plush toy. This helps prevent companies from buying into scams or purchasing counterfeit Beanie Babies

When you go to sell Beanie Babies, make sure you have a way to show its authenticity. Being able to authenticate your plush toys can increase Beanie Babies’ value. If you don’t have a certificate of authenticity, this may affect the Beanie Baby appraisal. 

Supply and Demand

Supply and demand are the next factors affecting a Beanie Baby appraisal. For example, rare Beanie Babies are more desirable than common Bean Babies. This desirability increases the demand for specific toys while the rarity means a decreased supply.

These two factors mean you can earn a lot of money if you go to sell rare Beanie Babies. However, it also means you should know your Beanie Babies’ value before accepting an offer. 

The selling price for rare Beanie Babies varies, but regardless of the price tag, certain Beanie Babies are highly sought after. Some of these rare Beanie Babies include:

  • Valentino the Bear
  • Princess the Bear
  • Punchers the Lobster
  • Iggy the Iguana
  • Patti the Platypus
  • Bubbles the Fish

Depending on the quality of these items, you could potentially make thousands of dollars on your old plush toys. Keep in mind, some of these toys are valued due to factory errors or printing mistakes on tags. This means that not every Iggy the Iguana, for example, will have the same outcome from a Beanie Baby appraisal. 

Item Quality

Item quality is the next consideration when it comes to your Beanie Babies’ value. Item quality considers general condition including stitching, tags, stuffing, and more. Condition is generally rated from mint condition to poor condition. 

If you’re looking to sell Beanie Babies in mint condition, you’ll make more than Beanie Babies in poor condition. Mint condition Beanie Babies are considered pristine. They appear as if they are brand-new and include any original packaging, accessories, and tags.


On the opposite end of the spectrum, poor condition Beanie Babies may have tears, stains, missing stuffing, or missing/damaged tags. While less desirable, you may still be able to sell Beanie Babies in poor condition.

Know What to Expect From Your Beanie Baby Appraisal

Know what to expect from your Beanie Baby appraisal by considering the above factors. Spend some time researching the supply and demand and item quality of your plush toys as well as whether they’re in mint condition or not. These factors greatly impact your Beanie Babies’ value should you decide to sell Beanie Babies.

If you feel confident about your plush toys, we’re ready to purchase them from you. Begin your sell order request today. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *