News flash: Some beanie babies are selling for more than $10,000 each. So if you’re wondering where to sell Beanie Babies for money, you’ve come to the right place.

Sick and tired of searching “who buys Ty Beanie Babies” online?

If you’re not sure where to sell Beanie Babies for the most money, find out where to sell your collection for the highest profits here!

Best Sites to Sell Beanie Baby Collections

Ready to start researching, “where to sell my Beanie Babies?”

Thankfully, the Internet is the best place to sell vintage toys, especially if you’re looking to get more bang for your buck.

But that’s not all — If you have special Beanie Babies, the best sites to sell your collection include the following options:

  • Craigslist
  • eBay
  • Etsy
  • PlushCollector

In case you didn’t know, Craigslist is a great way to connect with other vintage store collectors nearby if you’d like to support the local economy.

In addition to this, eBay is another common place to list your Beanie Babies for sale. Not only can you sell them out at a “flat rate,” but you can also auction them off, which may earn you even more cash in the long run.

And then, there is Etsy. Although there are tons of nostalgic toy buyers on this platform, most of them are only looking to purchase beanie babies at a much lower price range.

Last but not least, there is the PlushCollector.

As a specialty website, the PlushCollector is made for collectors who like to sell all sorts of collectibles, including Beanie Baby items. Plus, you may even qualify for free shipping if you sell a certain amount of merchandise!

How to Sell Beanie Babies Locally

Curious about where to sell Ty Beanie Babies locally?

We are glad that you asked!

If you’ve got a huge number of collectibles to get rid of, selling locally is the way to go. Even though you may not get the largest amount of cash for your collection, it may be the fastest way to sell your Beanie Babies quickly.

First of all, you might want to make a pit stop at your local antique shop. Since Beanie Babies are considered to be vintage toys, you might be able to pick up a pretty penny from your antique dealer, who will most likely resale your collection at a higher price.

Although antique dealers might offer lower fees than online buyers, this may be a good sale alternative if your Beanie Baby collection isn’t in the best condition. This is especially true because most collectors won’t want to pay premium dollars for used vintage toys.

Another smart idea is to set up a booth at your nearby flea market. If you’ve got a gigantic amount of Beanie Babies to sell, you may be able to sell a large number of them from haggling with flea market customers in person!

How Much Cash Beanie Babies Can Make

To be quite honest with you, most Beanie Babies won’t pull in that much cash. On average, you can expect to make up to $20 each for your every day, run-of-the-mill collection. However, you can make a ton of cash fast if you have a more valuable Beanie Baby in your collection.

For those of you who are new to selling Beanie Babies, the most premium toys include the following:

  • Bubbles
  • Claude the Crab
  • Valentino Beanie
  • Princess the Bear
  • Peace Bear
  • Patti the Platypus
  • Jake the Duck
  • Snort the Red Bull

Now that we’ve got that covered, the best way to figure out how much your Beanie Babies may be worth, look at what is sold on Etsy, eBay, or other platforms. This is the quickest way to figure out your ideal price range.

Found out that your Beanie Baby collection may not be worth that much money?

If all else fails, there’s nothing wrong with donating them to your local donation bin either!

More Beanie Baby Selling Tricks

Decided that you are ready to cash in on your Beanie Baby collection?

If that’s the case, take a look at a few ways to get more cash for your collection.

First of all, you might want to figure out which generation your Beanie Baby is from. This is extremely easy if you still have the original tag attached.

Once you look up the tag online, you can figure out what to price your toy at. Be sure to include any interesting details in your listing as well.

Besides this, consider the pellets that are used to stuff your Beanie Baby. If it’s stuffed with polyvinyl ethylene pellets, your toy will be worth much less than those that are stuffed with polyvinyl chloride pellets. Again, look at the tag to figure out what your toy is stuffed with.

In addition to this, you may want to join a Facebook group that focuses on selling collectible Beanie Babies. Not only can your fellow community members help you find the right price, but they may also even place an offer on your current collection.

Finally, be sure to take high-quality photos that highlight the condition and the tag of your Beanie Baby collection. Eye-catching and attention-grabbing angles for your thumbnail are key! 

Wondering Where to Sell Beanie Babies?

Not sure where to sell Beanie Babies for the highest price?

From how to sell Beanie Babies online to local dealers, we’ve got everything you need to succeed.

Still wondering who buys Beanie Babies?

Get in touch with one of our talented representatives today!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.