From their humble launch with only nine models, there are over 2,000 Beanie Baby collectibles today!

Beanie Babies were an undeniable craze of the late 1990s. Unfortunately, with the sweeping success of Beanie Babies, there came a few copycats. 

Do you have piles of old Beanies Babies worth money at home? Are you interested in collecting a rare beanie baby?

Check out this guide to make sure your Beanie Babies are the real deal!

How to Authenticate Beanie Babies

Some of the world’s most expensive Beanie Babies value as much as $500,000! During the Beanie Baby craze of the late 90s, many people began selling counterfeit eBay beanie babies, like Princess the Bear, to try to cash in on the trends. Although the craze has died down, there are still plenty of look-alikes on the market today.

There are several ways you can check the authenticity of your Beanie Babies. Before buying or selling a beanie baby, it’s a good idea to check these four areas. In some cases, a misprinted tag or discontinued model may even be worth more! 

1. Check the Tags

It’s true; Beanie Babies are worth more if they have the swing tag and tush tags still attached! Ty Beanie Babies have addresses and dates printed on their tags. Check these to make sure they match with the Beanie Baby they claim to be. 

If you can, compare the Beanie Baby tags to another Beanie Baby you’re sure is real. The tags shouldn’t be too light or dark in color, and they should have the same tag size and printed font. Older Beanie Baby tags have a bright yellow star, but counterfeits may have a star that looks dull, mustard-y, or too pointy. 

If your precious toys have lost their tags, don’t worry. There are still other ways to check for Beanie Baby’s value and authenticity. 

2. Check Size Proportions

Examine the Beanie Baby to assess its overall size, shape, and weight. Compare your Beanie Baby to an authenticated version. The legs, arms, ears, and other features should be in proportion to each other.

Fake Beanie Babies may have ears that are too large or too small. Arms and legs could be oddly shaped or too short in comparison to the body. If the head is too large or overstuffed, it could be a fake.  

3. Check the Eyes

Look closely at your Beanie Baby’s eyes. Counterfeit Beanie Babies may have eyes that are too close together or too far apart. Beanie Babies always have glass or plastic bead eyes, never stitched. 

Depending on the specific model, some Beanie Babies should have solid-colored eyes. Research the authentic design of your Beanie Baby to compare. If the toy has an incorrect eye color, it could likely be a fake. 

4. Check the Materials

If you can, feel the Beanie Baby with your hands and examine the material. Authentic Beanie Babies have a soft, plush fabric that doesn’t wrinkle. If the fabric feels too stiff, thin, or rough, it could be a counterfeit toy. 

If you’re buying online and can’t hold the Beanie Baby in your hand, look closely at the fabric color and sheen. Knock-offs may have fabric that is slightly lighter or darker than the real toy. Older, rarer Beanie Babies should have PVC pellets, which were swapped out for PE pellets in 1998

Is Your Toy Full of Beans?

Identifying real Beanie Babies can take some practice, so don’t feel down if you discover a fake in your collection. Although it may not be worth as much as the real thing, you can still enjoy playing with a soft and cuddly copycat Beanie Baby. 

Think you’ve got a bona fide Beanie Baby? Plush Collector wants your toys! Click here to find your Beanie Baby value! 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.